Display Cases in NYC: Best Stores & Custom Case Makers [Collector Guide]

Display Cases in NYC: Best Stores & Custom Case Makers [Collector Guide]

New York is swimming in display-case options, but most lists are written by big-box marketers—not by collectors who’ve tried shoving a PSA-slabbed Charizard or size-13 Off-White Jordan into a case and then dragged it up a fifth-floor walk-up. I’m the founder of QuirkShelv, a small team of UV-obsessed collectors who prototype, photograph, and stress-test cases every week. That means we know first-hand which chain stores carry decent off-the-shelf cubes, which Brooklyn fabricators return calls, and which “museum glass” is just fancy windowpane. This guide distills that hard-earned intel so you can skip the trial-and-error (and cracked acrylic) and go straight to a display that makes your collection pop—whether you’re showcasing Funko Grails, Yankees memorabilia, or a pair of glow-in-the-dark SB Dunks.


Big-Box & Craft Chains for a Same-Day Fix

Need a case tonight because that new PSA return is already warping on the windowsill? These chain stores keep decent stock in Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Queens—and most offer in-store pickup so you don’t have to gamble with porch pirates.

NYC location that actually has stock

What you’ll usually find

Street-smart tip

Michaels – Chelsea (675 6th Ave.)

Studio Décor basketball cubes, mirrored football cases, 16 × 20 shadow boxes

Screenshot the 20 % coupon in the app before you walk in.

The Container Store – 58 W 15th St.

Clear acrylic cubes up to 14″, risers, shelf-ready pods

Ask for “acrylic display cube”—staff will pull from top stockroom racks.

Blick Art Materials – Union Sq. (1 Astor Pl.)

Wood-front shadow boxes & deep frames to 24″ × 36″

Sign up for the free Pro card and snag an extra 10 % off.

Target – Herald Sq. (112 W 34th St.)

Threshold 11″ × 14″ black shadow-box frames—great for pins & small prints

Buy two and sandwich a tee for a budget jersey frame.

JOANN – Brooklyn (2955 Cropsey Ave.)

Clearance shadow boxes & flag cases while they last

The chain is liquidating, so expect fire-sale prices but limited sizes.

 

When good enough isn’t good enough
If you need UV-blocking acrylic or LED lighting, big-box inventory tops out fast. That’s where our QuirkShelv UV cases come in—purpose-built for graded slabs, sneakers, or whatever else you’re flexing.

Indie Hobby & Pop-Culture Shops (for Display Gear and Inspiration)

A trip to the 90s at Rudy's Hobby & Art - Epicenter NYC

New-York collectors know the real fun starts once you leave the mall and dive into the city’s nerd-mecca stores. Even if you don’t buy a case here, the wall setups alone will spark ideas for how to stage your own shelves.

 

Midtown Comics – Times Square flagship

  • Address: 200 W 40th St., 2nd floor (corner of 7th)
  • What to scout: BCW graded-card frames, miniature acrylic cubes for Hot Toys, and the occasional NECA lighted shadow box tucked by the checkout.
  • Collector hack: Staff will let you measure floor models—bring a tape to confirm sneaker or statue fit before you haul anything on the subway.

 

Forbidden Planet NYC – 832 Broadway (Union Sq.)

  • Why go: Their toy wall rotates weekly; you’ll find clear figure cubes and small risers next to the SH Figuarts. Great spot to test-fit 1/12-scale poses.
  • Reddit-style tip: Friday nights after 7 pm, they restock clearance bins—perfect for snagging a scuffed display box you can DIY-refinish.

 

Bleecker Trading – 96 Christopher St. & new UWS outpost

  • Focus: Modern sports and TCG cards displayed in sleek PSA/BGS wall cases; they even sell their own 12-slab acrylic frames.
  • Pro move: Snap pics of their recessed LED rail—exact lighting angle you’ll want for holo cards at home.
  • See how our QuirkShelv Dual-Slab UV Case compares → 2-Card Metal Premium PSA Card Display Case.

 

Image Anime (RIP, but worth a mention)

  • Once the Midtown haven for glass towers packed with Gundams and Masterpiece Transformers; it closed in early 2025, but the archived photos show clever “stair-step” riser layouts that maximize vertical space for 1/60 Valkyries.
  • Search “Image Anime tour” on YouTube for display inspo and to spot rare LED-mirrored cubes still floating around on resale apps.

 

Quick-Hit Honorable Mentions

  • Montasy Comics (31 St.) – budget Funko pop stacks and penny-sleeve supplies.
  • J&L Game (E 45th) – retro-game shop that carries dust-proof clamshells for cartridges.
  • Paragon Sports Memorabilia (Citi Field, seasonal) – jersey frames you can bring home post-game.

 

Can’t find the exact size?
NYC fabricators can cut acrylic to the millimetre—but if you’d rather skip the custom-quote dance, our made-to-fit QuirkShelv cases ship statewide in 48 hrs.

Custom Glass & Acrylic Fabricators in the Boroughs

When off-the-shelf just won’t cut it—think wall-to-wall Funko vaults or a sneaker throne sized for 14s—NYC’s local fabricators can build a showcase to the millimetre. Here are the shops collectors (and boutique retailers) keep on speed-dial:

Shop

Borough

What They Build

Typical Lead-Time

Street-Smart Tip

A&E Glass

Staten Island

Museum-grade glass cases with low-iron panels, UV options, on-site install

2–3 weeks

They’ll template on location—worth the $75 trip charge if your brownstone walls are less than square. newyorkglasscompany.co

4S Showcase MFG USA

East New York, Brooklyn

Full-vision retail towers, wall cases, kiosks; laminate color library

Quote-based (7–10 days for stock sizes)

Buy direct at the warehouse and they’ll toss in extra glass shelves—bring a van, they don’t deliver up flights. 4sshowcase.com

M. Fried Store Fixtures

Brownsville, Brooklyn

Ready-to-ship trophy cases (48″–72″) & custom LED showcases

In-stock cases same day; customs 3–4 weeks

Showroom lets you test lighting temps—snap pics to copy the glow at home. mfried.com

T&T Plastic Land

Manhattan (Canal St.)

Made-to-measure acrylic cubes, risers & laser-cut logos

3–5 business days

Bring your exact interior dims; they’ll trim lids while you wait (rare in NYC). T&T Plastic Land

 

Collectors’ note – most shops default to clear acrylic or standard float glass. If you need 99 % UV filtration or pre-wired LED puck lights, specify up front—or compare with our own How We Build UV-Safe Cases before signing a quote.

Online-First Brands That Get a Case to Your Door (or Lobby) Fast

Sometimes you’d rather skip the crosstown schlep and have a perfect-fit case show up while you’re sorting your latest COMC mail-day. These e-commerce specialists all ship to NYC—some even run same-day courier services if you can’t trust the building’s package room.

Brand

Sweet-Spot Products

How They Deliver to NYC

Collector’s Edge

QuirkShelv (that’s us)

UV-blocking PSA/BGS card frames, LED-lit sneaker thrones, magnetic-lid Funko cubes

48-hour UPS Ground to the five boroughs; messenger upgrade on request

Built by collectors—every design pressure-tested in a real NYC walk-up before launch. Check the full line → All Display Cases.

shopPOPdisplays

Five-sided acrylic cubes up to 24″, counter pedestals, lighted towers

New Jersey warehouse → FedEx Ground (1 day). Free freight on $300+ orders

Handy “quick-ship” section for standard sizes; custom cube builder if you know your exact dims.

Pedestal Source

Laminate or wood plinths, ambient-light pedestals, museum-style vitrines

Freight to curb within 3–5 days; white-glove inside-delivery add-on

Instagram-ready lighting kits—great for statues or sneaker grails you want floating in glow.

Gaylord Archival

Conservation-grade flag cases, linen-lined tabletop vitrines

UPS 2-Day; truck freight for large exhibit cases

Archival foam & 99 % UV acrylic—choose these if you’re guarding paper memorabilia or vintage jerseys.

Displays2Go

Retail towers, countertop glass showcases, wall vitrines

Same-day ship on many SKUs; 3-5 day ground to NYC

Frequent sales—sign up for their list and wait for the 15 % coupon before pulling the trigger.

 

Shipping math 101
Big glass towers can blow past free-freight thresholds—measure your elevator and lobby doorway first so you’re not tipping the freight driver to re-attempt delivery. If you’re in a doorman-free walk-up, consider the courier upgrade or have it sent to your office.

Heads-up on UV claims
“UV-resistant” isn’t the same as “UV-blocking.” Look for 92 % filtration or higher if you’re protecting signatures or vintage paper. (Our cases clock in at 98–99 %, lab-tested.)

Ready to level-up? Compare our Dual-Slab UV Display with any of the above and see why local graders keep sliding into our DMs → 2-Card Metal Premium PSA Card Display Case.

NYC Collector’s Pre-Purchase Checklist

No, NYC Subways Still Aren't Safe | Manhattan Institute

Measure twice, subway once
Before you add to cart—or hail a yellow cab—grab a tape and note three numbers:

  • Case footprint vs. building entryway (many prewar doors top out at 28″).
  • Stairwell turns—fifth-floor walk-ups often have a single 29-inch landing; glass towers love to wedge.
  • Shelf depth inside the case; PSA slabs need at least 0.34″ clearance in front of the acrylic lip.

UV or bust
LED light strips look killer, but sunlight bouncing off a neighboring high-rise will fade signatures fast. Check the spec sheet for ≥ 92 % UV filtration. (All QuirkShelv acrylic clocks in at 98 – 99 %; see test data in our Collector Tips post.)

Dust-seal details
Look for tongue-and-groove lids or magnetic doors. NYC windows bring in soot that’ll cake on Funko boxes within weeks.

Lighting that flatters, not fries

  • 3000 K–4000 K LEDs keep colors true.
  • Avoid halogen pucks—heat warps slab sleeves.
    Need a primer? We break down color temps in How to Light Your Display.

Wall-mounting & landlord rules
Most prewar plaster won’t hold a 40-lb. tower on toggle bolts alone. Ask your super about stud placement or budget the ~$150 TaskRabbit fee for professional anchor install.

Insurance & valuations
Renters policies usually cap collectibles at $1 k. Schedule high-value items separately or add a rider before you drill.

Sales-tax hacks
NYC’s combined rate is 8.875 % (4 % state + 4.5 % city + 0.375 % MCTD)
City of New York. Buying online from an out-of-state shop still triggers that rate at checkout, but many brands waive it during seasonal promos—join their email lists and stack coupons with free-freight thresholds.

Ready with your tape measure and UV wish-list? Jump to our curated lineup of UV-safe cases and pick the size that fits—no stairwell Tetris required.

Wrap-Up: Build Your Own Mini-Museum

New York hands you every display option on a silver platter—craft-store shadow boxes for an emergency pick-up, indie hobby shops for niche acrylic cubes, borough-based fabricators when you need a custom wall of glass, and online specialists that courier a UV-safe case straight to your lobby. Plug those choices into the checklist from Section 6 and you’ll sidestep warped slabs, sun-bleached grails, and stairwell heartbreak.

If you’re after zero-guesswork protection (and lighting dialed for Instagram close-ups), browse the QuirkShelv UV Display lineup—each case tested in a real NYC walk-up, so you know it actually fits through a narrow prewar doorway.

Got a secret spot for display cases we missed? Drop your intel—or flex a photo of your finished setup—in the comments below. Collectors helping collectors is how New York keeps its nerd cred strong. See you there, and happy flexing!

Back to blog

Leave a comment